Chat
Chat with Sales Hours: Monday-Friday 8:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m. (CST)
Contact Sales
Call Sales Toll-Free 1-(866) 774-3282 Hours: Monday-Friday 7 a.m. - 5 p.m. (CST)
Product Login
Product Log-in
Product Support
Product Support
Email Sales
Contact Sales
After Hours
  • Support
  • Sign In Sign In
  • AUS NZ UK
CoreLogic - Home
  • Solutions
    view solutions by:

    Data Solutions

    • Lead Generation
    • Property Data
    • Location Intelligence

    Real Estate

    • Multiple Listing Enterprise
    • Agent & Broker

    Mortgage

    • Origination
    • Servicing
    • Appraisal
    • Commercial Property Tax

    Insurance

    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management
    • Risk Evaluation
    • Underwriting Automation
    • Weather
    • Claims Automation
    • Restoration
    • INTRCONNECT

    Mortgage Lenders

    • Origination

    Mortgage Servicers

    • Residential Property Tax
    • Default & Loss Mitigation
    • Portfolio Insight & Monitoring

    Mortgage Appraisers

    • Appraisal

    Real Estate Agents & Brokers

    • Agents & Brokers

    Real Estate MLS

    • Multiple Listing Enterprises

    Commercial Real Estate Owners

    • Commercial Property Tax

    Marketing Departments

    • Property Data

    Insurance Underwriters

    • Risk Evaluation
    • Underwriting Automation
    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management

    Insurance Risk Managers

    • Risk Evaluation
    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management

    Insurance Claims

    • Claims Automation
    • Restoration Contractors
    • Weather Verification

    Construction Contractors

    • Restoration Contractors

    General

    • Location Intelligence
    • Lead Generation
    • Data Solutions
  • Resources

    Reports

    • Climate Change
    • Construction Cost Update
    • Construction Insights
    • Home Price Insights
    • Homeowner Equity Insights
    • Loan Performance Insight
    • Mortgage Fraud
    • Property Tax Delinquency
    • Single-Family Rent Index

    Insight Blogs

    • Hazard HQ
    • Office of Chief Economist
    • Affordable Housing
    • Homebuying
    • Insurance
    • Other Articles

    More Resources

    • Events
    • Case Studies
    • White Papers
    • Podcasts
    • Quick Takes
  • Company
    • About
    • Leadership
    • Newsroom
    • Contact
    • Careers
  • Search
CoreLogic - Home
  • Solutions
  • Resources
  • Company

    • About
    • Leadership
    • Newsroom
    • Contact
    • Careers
  • Accounts

    • Products Sign-in
  • Contact

    • Sales Contact
    • Product Support
  • Regions

    • Australia
    • New Zealand
    • United Kingdom
  • Social

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Linkedin
    • Twitter
    • Youtube
Solutions
VIEW BY:
  • Data Solutions

    • Lead Generation
    • Property Data
    • Location Intelligence
  • Real Estate

    • Multiple Listing Enterprise
    • Agent & Broker
  • Mortgage

    • Origination
    • Servicing
    • Appraisal
    • Commercial Property Tax
  • Insurance

    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management
    • Risk Evaluation
    • Underwriting Automation
    • Weather
    • Claims Automation
    • Restoration
    • INTRCONNECT
  • Mortgage Lenders

    • Origination
  • Mortgage Servicers

    • Residential Property Tax
    • Default & Loss Mitigation
    • Portfolio Insight & Monitoring
  • Mortgage Appraisers

    • Appraisal
  • Real Estate Agents & Brokers

    • Agents & Brokers
  • Real Estate MLS

    • Multiple Listing Enterprises
  • Commercial Real Estate Owners

    • Commercial Property Tax
  • Marketing Departments

    • Property Data
  • Insurance Underwriters

    • Risk Evaluation
    • Underwriting Automation
    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management
  • Insurance Risk Managers

    • Risk Evaluation
    • Hazard Risk
    • Catastrophe Risk Management
  • Insurance Claims

    • Claims Automation
    • Restoration Contractors
    • Weather Verification
  • Construction Contractors

    • Restoration Contractors
  • General

    • Location Intelligence
    • Lead Generation
    • Data Solutions
Resources
  • Reports

    • Climate Change
    • Construction Cost Update
    • Construction Insights
    • Home Price Insights
    • Homeowner Equity Insights
    • Loan Performance Insight
    • Mortgage Fraud
    • Property Tax Delinquency
    • Single-Family Rent Index
  • Insight Blogs

    • Hazard HQ
    • Office of Chief Economist
    • Affordable Housing
    • Homebuying
    • Insurance
    • Other Articles
  • More Resources

    • Events
    • Case Studies
    • White Papers
    • Podcasts
    • Quick Takes

Home / Intelligence / Expiration of the CFPB’s Qualified Mortgage (QM) GSE Patch – Part V

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Peter Carroll
Peter Carroll
Executive, Public Policy and Industry Relations
View Profile
  • January 13, 2020

Expiration of the CFPB’s Qualified Mortgage (QM) GSE Patch – Part V

Further insights on balancing risks (loan delinquency) and benefits (mortgage credit access) in the QM Safe Harbor, following expiration of the GSE Patch


In our previous blog, Part IV of our QM blog series, we examined the balance of risks (loan delinquency) and benefits (mortgage credit access) in the QM Safe Harbor following expiration of the GSE Patch.

In this follow up we further validate our empirical evidence by analyzing loan delinquency by rate spread category for both purchase and refinance loans originated in 2018.[1] Our previous blog analyzed a 2010-2017 cohort of home-purchase loans. Because HMDA did not require reporting of rate spreads below 1.5% until 2018, the previous analysis was unable to compare loan delinquency for rate spread categories below 1.5% for Conventional loans.

Beginning in 2018, HMDA requires most lenders to report rate spread on all loans whether negative or positive with a minimum of 3 decimal points. Conventional loans are classified as QM Rebuttable Presumption loans (Higher-Priced Mortgage Loans) if the Annual Percentage Rate (APR) exceeds the Average Prime Offer Rate (APOR) for loans of a similar type by at least 1.5 percentage points for first-lien loans or 3.5 percentage points for junior-lien loans.[2] As mentioned in blog Part IV, Conventional loans that are not higher-priced, i.e. with rate spread below 1.5%, are deemed QM Safe Harbor.

Figure 1 displays 60-day, 90-day, and early payment default (EPD) delinquency rates for Conventional loans.[3] The delinquency rates are displayed by rate spread category, in increments of 0.25 percentage points. Consistent with our prior analysis, Figure 1 shows that the delinquency rate was lowest for loans with a rate spread below 0 and highest for the loans with rate spreads above 2.0%. There were notable increases in loan delinquency as rate spreads increased. However, also consistent with our prior analysis, we observe little variation overall in the Conventional loan delinquency rates between the 1.25% – 1.49% and 1.50% – 1.74% rate spread categories, respectively: EPD rates were about the same for each rate spread category (0.5%), and the 60 day delinquency rate was only slightly higher for the 1.50% – 1.74% rate spread category (1.8%) as compared with the 1.25% – 1.49% rate spread category (1.6%). While the factors that might account for these variations will require further research, the similarity in Conventional loan delinquency rates from 1.25% over APOR through 1.74% over APOR further suggests that closer examination into whether the QM Safe Harbor rate spread cap is appropriately calibrated, all things equal, is reasonable.

As reviewed in blog Part IV, Credit Score and Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI) are today two underwriting criteria (among others) that help an underwriter assess borrower ability-to-repay and are also among a broader set of underwriting criteria used today to price credit risk.[4] Consistent with blog Part IV, analysis of 2018 merged LLMA and HMDA data demonstrates that as the underwriting attributes of a loan degraded, rate spread (loan pricing) and borrower delinquency both increased. For example, rate spreads are higher for Conventional loans with lower Credit Scores and higher DTIs to compensate for the additional expected delinquency risk. Figures 2-3 demonstrate averages of Credit Scores and DTI by rate spread category for Conventional home-purchase loans originated in 2018.

In conclusion, our analysis of 2018 merged CoreLogic LLMA and HMDA data appears to validate and reinforce our findings from blog Part IV. As borrower ability-to-repay (capacity)-related underwriting attributes deteriorated, the rate spread (loan pricing) and borrower loan delinquency both increased.

When considering the impacts of the expiration of the GSE Patch, policymakers ultimately have a difficult judgment call to make with respect to whether the benefit of increasing the QM Safe Harbor rate spread cap (loan pricing) for Conventional loans exceeds the risks of increased borrower loan delinquency (a proxy for borrower repayment sustainability), all things equal. Moreover, regardless of whether the QM Safe Harbor rate spread cap is ultimately increased, consideration of the proper role for ability-to-repay-specific underwriting criteria (including methods for calculating underwriting criteria and verifying borrower financial resources) in a new ATR/QM Rule is warranted. These judgments become particularly relevant in the event our economy experiences a recession, placing upward pressure on delinquency rates.

[1] CoreLogic Loan-Level Market Analytics (LLMA) data was merged with 2010-2018 HMDA data by employing a unique matching technique that linked LLMA loan performance data to HMDA origination data. The match was based on loan characteristics, such as the loan amount, the loan purpose, the loan type, census tract, origination year, and the lender identity key. The overall match rate was about 50% of the LLMA data. Performance of loans were tracked as of October 2019. We include both purchase and refinance loans in our loan delinquency analysis to provide a comprehensive review.

[2] See CFPB website https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-is-a-higher-priced-mortgage-loan-en-1797/

[3] Early payment default is defined as 90 days or more past due within the first year of mortgage origination.

[4] Underwriting methodologies are often referenced according to the “Three C’s” of “Capacity, Credit, Collateral.” “Capacity” refers to the borrower’s ability to repay their mortgage loan, all things equal. DTI is a traditional underwriting measure for this purpose. “Credit” refers to both borrower ability to repay but also, importantly, their willingness to repay; a borrower could have the ability to repay their loan, but their past credit history indicates that they choose not to nonetheless. Credit Score is a traditional underwriting measure of borrower Credit (as well as Capacity). Finally, “Collateral” refers to the borrower’s down payment or “skin in the game,” which bears on both their willingness to repay, but also serves as an important lender mitigator of loss severity; in the event the borrower defaults on their mortgage loan, the greater the borrower’s equity, the lower the loss severity for the lender. Loan-to-Value Ratio (LTV) is a traditional underwriting measure of Collateral. Given that QM is part of an Ability-to-Repay Rule, our analyses focus on DTI and Credit Score as two underwriting measures considered common to assessing borrower ability to repay today. Other underwriting criteria could augment or replace these measures including borrower cash flow analyses and liquid asset reserves. It is also important to note that APR (i.e., the “all-in” pricing of the loan) is intended to be a reflection of the “Three C’s” holistically. As such, while borrower ability to repay is certainly reflected in the APR, it is not the only consideration reflected in the APR.

© 2020 CoreLogic, All rights reserved

  • Category: Blogs, Homebuying, Intelligence
  • Tags: GSE Patch, Mortgage, Qualified Mortgages
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Peter Carroll
Peter Carroll
Executive, Public Policy and Industry Relations
View Profile

Related Posts

Tornado footprints in Southern California captured by CoreLogic's weather verification technology as viewed in CoreLogic Reactor™.
Blogs

A Rare Los Angeles Tornado and Near Hurricane-Force Winds in San Francisco

CoreLogic Weather Verification Services captured wind and tornado footprints from the severe weather system in California.

March 24, 2023
atmospheric rivers california
Core Conversations

What Was it Really Like to Live Through the California Floods? Our Team Spills

A Conversation With Kent David and Tom Larsen Since the beginning of the year, California has been drenched by atmospheric rivers. The flooding in California

March 22, 2023
Ecuador earthquake
Blogs

M6.8 Earthquake Near the Coast of Ecuador

CoreLogic estimates that insurable losses from the Ecuador earthquake will be up to $600 million.

March 21, 2023

About Corelogic

  • Newsroom
  • Leadership
  • Careers
  • Ethics & Compliance

Accounts

  • Products Sign-in

Contact

  • Sales Contact
  • Product Support

Regions

  • CoreLogic Australia
  • CoreLogic New Zealand
  • CoreLogic UK

Follow & Connect

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
© 2023 CoreLogic. All rights reserved.
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • CCPA
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Security
  • Sitemap
  • Accessibility
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • CCPA
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Security
  • Sitemap
  • Accessibility